Most Expensive Diamond Colors With Prices Explained


Looking at fancy colored diamonds? Discover unique diamond colors with our guide and learn how the pricing of these gems can vary.

8 Minute Read

HomeDiamond AdviceThe 4 Cs of Diamonds - ColorMost Expensive Diamond Colors With Prices Explained

IGS may receive customer referral fees from the companies listed in this page.

By Amanda Butcher, updated on

Are you fascinated by the world of colored diamonds? This guide takes you through everything you need to know about these rare treasures, from how they form to what makes them so valuable.

In this article, you will:

  • Learn about the natural formation process of colored diamonds and what makes them so rare.
  • Understand colored diamonds pricing and what makes them different from colorless diamonds.
  • Get detailed information on what the most valuable diamond colors are (red, blue, pink, and yellow).
  • Explore price comparisons between colored natural and lab-grown diamonds.
  • Gain expert insights into what makes certain diamond colors more valuable than others.

In this video, Jake Talve-Goodman of The Concierge Gemologist introduces viewers to the world of fancy colored diamonds and explains how they form and get their beautiful colors.

Are Natural Fancy Colored Diamonds Rare?

Just like their colorless counterparts, fancy colored diamonds form naturally from carbon deep beneath the Earth's surface at temperatures exceeding 1000 degrees Celsius over millions of years. These diamonds develop their extraordinary colors through rare changes to their chemical structure during formation, which alters how they reflect light and influences the colors we perceive.

  • These natural color variations occur in only 0.1% of all diamonds mined globally.
  • The rare molecular alterations create spectacular colors spanning the entire spectrum.
  • Natural fancy colored diamonds include pink, purple, blue, yellow, brown, and numerous other hues.
  • Each colored diamond's unique structure makes it one of nature's rarest treasures.
The natural pink diamond in this ring was formed in the earth millions of years ago. © James Allen
Find this ring
at James Allen

How are Fancy Colored Diamonds Priced?

Gemologists evaluate and price diamonds of color using the traditional Four Cs: cut, clarity, carat, and color. While cut, clarity, and carat assessments follow standard diamond grading principles, the color grading system for diamonds differs significantly from that used for colorless stones.

  • Nearly 30 base colors can create over 200 unique color combinations.
  • Laboratory graders determine specific color names by examining both primary and secondary hues.
  • For example, a green diamond with blue undertones would be classified as "blueish green".
  • Graders assess the hue, tone, and saturation to determine the diamond's fancy color designation.
0.75 Carat Fancy Blueish Green-SI2 Radiant Cut Diamond at Blue NIle
Find this Diamond
at Blue Nile

The intensity of the color determines the grade, with rankings from least to most saturated as follows: faint, very light, light, fancy light, fancy, fancy intense, fancy vivid, fancy dark, and fancy deep. Generally, deeper and more intense colors command higher prices in the diamonds market.

Colored diamonds come in an vast array of colors. © Brian Gavin
Find these Diamonds
at Brian Gavin

Red Diamonds: The Rarest Diamond Color in the World

Red diamonds represent the ultimate rarity in the colored diamond world, with only 20-30 known to exist worldwide. These extraordinary gems develop their breathtaking crimson color through an extremely rare process during formation that alters the crystal structure, causing light to interact differently than with colorless diamonds.

  • This unique formation process is so exceptional that red diamonds typically range from just half a carat to one carat in size.
  • Their extreme rarity and intense red coloration make them the most expensive colored diamonds per carat.
  • Red diamonds are the ultimate collector's gem due to their scarcity.
  • Most red diamonds display pure red color with minimal secondary hues.

Red Diamond Prices

On average, red diamonds command prices exceeding $1 million per carat, making them the most valuable colored diamonds by weight. The largest red diamond ever sold at auction weighed 5.11 carats and fetched a total of $8 million, representing approximately $1.6 million per carat.

Collectors and investors seeking these exceptional rarities can explore options at retailers like Blue Nile, which offers a selection of colored diamonds including some of these extraordinary specimens.

This rare 0 .71 carat red diamond can be bought for $695,800 at Blue Nile.

Blue Diamonds: Rare Boron-Infused Treasures

Blue diamonds derive their mesmerizing color from the element boron, which substitutes for some carbon atoms within the diamond crystal structure. This unique composition can produce everything from subtle blue tints to deep, rich azure hues that captivate collectors worldwide.

  • Only a few mines in Australia, India, and South Africa produce natural blue diamonds.
  • While less rare than red diamonds, blue diamonds often grow larger and can command higher total prices.
  • Blue diamonds display various intensity levels from light sky blue to intense deep blue.
  • The presence of boron in these diamonds makes them natural semiconductors.

Blue Diamond Prices

The average medium-toned 1-carat blue diamond can cost approximately $200,000, with prices increasing significantly with color intensity and size. The most expensive blue diamond ever sold at auction was a 14.2-carat fancy vivid blue specimen, which achieved $3.9 million per carat for a total price of $57.5 million.

This impressive figure seems modest in comparison to the estimated value of the famous Hope Diamond, currently housed at the Smithsonian Institution. The famous blue diamond weighs 45.2 carats and has an estimated value of $250 million. James Allen offer a diverse selection of these blue treasures with 360-degree viewing technology.

This .75 carat dazzling blue diamond with VS2 clarity can be found at James Allen for $65,820
Find this Diamond
at James Allen

Pink Diamonds: Mysterious Rose-Colored Gems

Pink diamonds rank among the rarest diamonds, with most originating from a single source: the Argyle mine in Australia. Although their rarity compares to that of blue diamonds, pink diamonds often command higher prices due to strong demand for their romantic, delicate coloration.

  • Pink diamonds remain a scientific mystery, as the exact cause of their color is still unknown to gemologists.
  • Unlike other colored diamonds, they contain no trace elements but have a different crystal structure.
  • This unique structure reflects the enchanting pink hues we admire.
  • Pink diamonds mined outside the Argyle mine typically cost less but remain extremely valuable.

Pink Diamond Prices

The price per carat for pink diamonds varies considerably based on size, color intensity, and clarity. This wide variation means pink diamond prices can range from $10,000 to over $700,000 per carat for exceptional specimens.

The most celebrated pink diamond, known as the "Pink Star," weighs an impressive 59.6 carats and sold for $71.2 million in 2017, representing approximately $1.19 million per carat. This record-breaking sale demonstrates the extraordinary value collectors place on these rose-colored treasures.

0.42-Carat Intense Pink Round Diamond Blue NIle

Yellow Diamonds: The Most Popular Colored Diamonds

Yellow and brown diamonds constitute more than half of the colored diamond market. Though still rare compared to colorless diamonds, their relatively lower price point and striking appearance have made yellow diamonds the most sought-after colored diamonds among consumers.

  • Yellow diamonds get their sunny color from nitrogen atoms, which absorb blue light.
  • They frequently occur with various secondary colors creating unique combinations.
  • Canary Yellow Diamonds, describing pure fancy yellow diamonds, are the most prized variety.
  • Their relatively higher availability makes them more accessible to collectors.

Yellow Diamond Prices

Due to their greater availability, yellow diamonds typically cost significantly less per carat than other colored diamonds. Some light yellow diamonds may even be priced below comparable colorless diamonds of similar size and quality.

  • Average prices for yellow diamonds of good clarity and color range from $3,000-$5,000 per carat.
  • Fancy vivid yellow diamonds command premium prices of $8,000-$16,000 per carat.
  • The record-setting yellow diamond sale was the Graff Vivid Yellow, weighing 100.90 carats.
  • This extraordinary gem sold for $16.3 million in 2020, demonstrating the investment potential of exceptional yellow diamonds.
This stunning yellow diamond engagement ring is available at Blue Nile for $3500
Find this Ring
at Blue Nile

Lab-Grown Colored Diamonds: Affordable Alternatives with Identical Properties

The extreme rarity of natural colored diamonds makes them prohibitively expensive for many consumers, but lab-grown colored diamonds provide a more accessible alternative. These created diamonds possess identical physical and optical properties to mined diamonds but are produced in controlled laboratory environments.

  • Labs can recreate the same structural variations that give natural diamonds their color.
  • Lab-grown colored diamonds can be produced in greater quantities and larger sizes.
  • A synthetic 1-carat blue diamond costs approximately $8,500, compared to $200,000 for a mined equivalent.
  • Lab-grown diamonds have a significantly reduced environmental footprint.

This combination of affordability and sustainability makes lab-grown colored diamonds an increasingly popular choice for consumers. Retailers like Blue Nile offer extensive collections of lab-grown diamonds suitable for creating stunning and environmentally responsible jewelry.

This pink lab-grown diamond ring is available at Blue Nile for $600
Find this Ring
at Blue Nile

Frequently Asked Questions About Colored Diamonds

What makes colored diamonds different from regular diamonds?

Colored diamonds have the same carbon composition as colorless diamonds but contain trace elements or structural anomalies that create their unique colors. These variations occur in only 0.1% of all diamonds, making colored diamonds extremely rare.

Which colored diamond is the most expensive?

Red diamonds are the most expensive colored diamonds per carat, often exceeding $1 million per carat due to their extreme rarity. Only 20-30 natural red diamonds are known to exist worldwide.

How are fancy colored diamonds graded?

Fancy colored diamonds are graded using the Four Cs (cut, clarity, carat, and color) like colorless diamonds. However, their color is evaluated based on hue (primary and secondary colors), tone, and saturation. The color intensity scale ranges from faint to fancy vivid, with more intense colors commanding higher prices.

Are colored diamonds a good investment?

Rare colored diamonds, particularly those with intense colors and larger sizes, have historically appreciated in value. Blue, pink, and red diamonds have shown strong investment performance, though market conditions can vary. Lab-grown diamonds are more affordable but typically don't appreciate in value like natural stones.

Can you tell the difference between natural and lab-grown colored diamonds?

Both have identical physical and chemical properties. Gemological laboratories can distinguish them using specialized equipment that detects subtle growth patterns and inclusions characteristic of each formation process.

Which mines produce colored diamonds?

The Argyle mine in Australia was famous for pink diamonds before closing in 2020. Blue diamonds come primarily from mines in South Africa, India, and Australia. Yellow diamonds are found in several locations worldwide, with significant sources in Africa and Russia.


Amanda Butcher

Amanda is a student of geological sciences and environmental studies at Tufts University. She grew up hiking and mountain biking in the Bay Area and continues to explore nature and learn about the beautiful gems and minerals it forms in her free time.

Never Stop Learning

When you join the IGS community, you get trusted diamond & gemstone information when you need it.

Become a Member

Get Gemology Insights

Get started with the International Gem Society’s free guide to gemstone identification. Join our weekly newsletter & get a free copy of the Gem ID Checklist!